Placing an Esrog Between Apples on Shabbos to Help It Turn Yellow
- Sukkos
- 5787
- English
Q: When the first day of Sukkos falls on Shabbos, there is a question whether one may intentionally place an esrog between apples on Friday night so that it may become more yellow by Sunday morning, when he will fulfill the mitzvah.
A: The question is whether this involves a concern of tzove'a (coloring), tikkun mana (fixing an object), muktzeh, or hachana (preparing on Shabbos for after Shabbos). In Shu't Mishnas Yosef (VII, siman 77 s.k. 5), it is written that although we rule that there is no prohibition of tzove'a with regard to food, nevertheless, since the esrog has been set aside for the mitzvah, it is difficult to say that it is considered ordinary food. Furthermore, this is not really an act of coloring, but rather the ripening of a green fruit that has not yet fully ripened. According to this, however, it would seemingly be prohibited because of tikkun mana, unless the esrog is not green like a leek and one merely wishes to return it between the apples in order to allow it to ripen further, in which case it presumably would not be considered tikkun mana.
Rav Yom Tov Zanger Shlit"a in his sefer Madanei Zahav writes, It seems to me that there is a difficulty with his initial reasoning. The possibility that this should be permitted because there is no tzove'a with food is very difficult, because if the purpose is to improve the appearance of the food, it is prohibited, as the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 320 s.k. 56) writes in the name of the Pri Megadim (ibid., Eishel Avraham s.k. 25) regarding adding color to whiskey intended for sale (see also Kehillos Yaakov, Shabbos, siman 40). As for his stringency based on the fact that the esrog has been set aside for the mitzvah, this too is difficult, because we are discussing the period before Sukkos, when it cannot be said that the esrog has already been designated for the mitzvah, since we rule that hazmanah lav milsa hi (see Biur Halachah, O.C. 665 s.v. v'harei). Nevertheless, even according to his approach, there is room to be lenient when the esrog is not green like a leek. The Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 648 s.k. 65) writes that if the esrog has already begun, to some degree, to return to the normal color of an esrog, it is kosher. Therefore, in such a case, it would seemingly not be considered tikkun mana.
We can also add the opinion of Rashi in Shabbos (74b), who explains that one who places a barrel into a kiln in order to harden it does not violate makeh b'patish, since the process is completed on its own. Perhaps the same reasoning can be applied to our esrog, which is simply placed between apples and ripens on its own. However, the Minchas Chinuch (mitzvah 32, Melaches Ofeh, melachah 11, os 7) cites the Rosh in Beitzah (34a), who disagrees with Rashi on this point, and he remains with a tzarich iyun.
In Shu't Machazeh Eliyahu (I, siman 65, s.k. 24), it is written that it has not been clearly established whether the melachah of tzove'a applies when no color is actually being placed onto the object, but rather the color changes only through a chemical process. He writes that this has practical relevance to our case, where a person performs an action in order to cause an esrog to become yellow. He compares this to a person intentionally sitting in the sun so that the heat of the sun will cause his skin to become somewhat darker, or wearing sunglasses that turn dark when exposed to sunlight.
There is also a concern of hachana, since the esrog will not be used on Shabbos. In Shu't Shevet HaKehati (IV, siman 176), it is written that there is no prohibition of hachana, since one may place the esrog wherever he wishes. I subsequently saw that Maran HaRav Elyashiv zt"l permitted placing an esrog between apples on Shabbos. He explained that this is not considered tikkun, since the esrog is kosher even without this process, and it is not considered tzove'a, since nothing new is being added; rather, the green color is being removed.