Skip to content
Kollel Lihoraah - English

A Jew Who Wishes to Sell Colored Candles

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

A Jew Who Wishes to Sell Colored Candles

Q: Regarding our discussion, another question arises concerning a Jew who sells these types of candles throughout the year: Is he permitted to sell them to a non -Jew who intends to use them in honor of his holiday?

A: In Shu't Shivtei Yisrael I (siman 23), the question was asked regarding colored candles that a Jew wishes to sell to storekeepers, when it is known that these candles are used for the idolatrous practices of non-Jews, although they are sometimes also used for permissible purposes. Is he permitted to sell them, or should he be concerned that the storekeeper will sell them to houses of wor-ship? He discusses the matter at length with regard to the laws of lifnei d'lefnei and other considerations, and combines several reasons why even a person who wishes to be stringent does not need to do so. See there for the full discussion. In Mar'os Yechezkel I (p. 456), Rav Yechezkal Roth zt"l was asked whether a Jew may purchase candles intended for avodah zarah from one non-Jew and sell them to another non-Jew, as well as whether someone who owns a candle store may sell such candles when non-Jews come into his store. He ruled that if a non-Jew purchases a large quantity from him, making it apparent that he is purchasing them for commercial purposes, it is permissible. Regarding the second question, he ruled that if a person owns a store where various people, including non-Jews, come to purchase candles, and they wish to purchase candles that are known to be intended for their holiday, if he cannot avoid selling them, he should take a non-Jewish partner into the store and stipu-late with him from the outset that part of the candles belong to the non-Jew. A non-Jewish employee should then hand the candles to the non-Jewish customer at the time of the sale. See also Shu't Emek HaTeshuvah VIII (siman 94).

More in this printout

View the whole printout