Skip to content
Parsha Pages

HALLEL

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Overview of the Structure

Hallel is made up of six consecutive chapters in Tehillim, Psalms 113-118. Though they are all clearly centered around the theme of praising HaShem for salvation, it is not as obvious how each psalm flow into the next and whether there is an overarching structure to the prayer as a whole. Three possible ways of structuring the prayer follow, each highlighting a somewhat different relationship between the various chapters.

Collective and Individual Salvation

Hallel can be divided into two main units, Chapters 113-115 which focus on collective salvation, and Chapters 116-118, which focus on individual salvation. Each half can be further subdivided into chapters of praise and request. Whereas the first half begins with praise and ends with request, the second half does the opposite, starting with request and ending with praise. This ensures that Hallel is appropriately book-ended by praise, with the requests sandwiched in the middle.

  1. Collective Salvation (Chapters 113-115)
    1. Praise (Chapters 113-114)
      1. General Providence: (Chapter 113).
      2. National Providence (Chapter 114)
    2. Request (Chapter 115)
  2. Individual Salvation (Chapters 116-118)
    1. Request (Chapters 116)
    2. Praise (Chapter 117-118)

This division might reflect the two types of occasions on which Hallel is recited, on national holidays, and in thanksgiving for "any calamity" which befalls one.

Praise, Request, and Thanks

Hallel can be divided into three units, like the Amidah prayer, that move from praise, to request, to thanksgiving:

  1. Praise (Chapters 113-114)
    • Universal: G-d's providence in the World (Chapter 113)
    • National: G-d's providence over Israel (Chapter 114)
  2. Request: Call for Salvation (Chapters 115-116)
    • National (Chapter 115)
    • Individual (Chapter 116)
  3. Thanksgiving: Salvation Granted (Chapters 117-118)
    • Universal: Recognition of G-d by Foreigners (Chapter 117)
    • Individual: Thanksgiving and Fulfilling of Vow (Chapter 118)

This structure might view the first unit as an introduction, and the second and third units as the heart of Hallel, in which a prayer is proffered and answered, leading to thanks. The numerous points of contact between these latter units highlights the correlation between the request and thanksgiving

  • In Psalm 115 the speaker calls on three groups, יִשְׂרָאֵל, בֵית אַהֲרֹן, יִרְאֵי י"י to trust in G-d, and requests of HaShem to bless each group. In chapter 118, it calls on these same groups, this time to thank HaShem.
  • In Psalm 115, as part of his request for salvation, the psalmist says, "לֹא הַמֶּתִים יְהַלְלוּ יָהּ". In Chapter 118, when thanking HaShem, the speaker echoes: "לֹא אָמוּת כִּי אֶחְיֶה וַאֲסַפֵּר מַעֲשֵׂי יָהּ".
  • In Psalm 116 the speaker promises to bring a thanksgiving offering for his salvation ("לָךְ אֶזְבַּח זֶבַח תּוֹדָה"). This vow is fulfilled in Chapter 118, as the speaker says,"אִסְרוּ חַג בַּעֲבֹתִים".
  • Psalm 116:3 speaks of being surrounded by cords of death ("אֲפָפוּנִי חֶבְלֵי מָוֶת") while 118:10 speaks of being surrounded by enemies ("כָּל גּוֹיִם סְבָבוּנִי").
  • In 116:3 the speaker requests salvation from "מְצָרֵי שְׁאוֹל". Psalm 118:5 echoes,"מִן הַמֶּצַר קָרָאתִי" adding ."עָנָנִי בַמֶּרְחָב יָהּ"
  • When requesting salvation, the speaker says, "וּבְשֵׁם י"י אֶקְרָא" (116:4). When expressing thanks, one says, "קָרָאתִי יָהּ" (118:5).
  • In 116:8, the speaker requests salvation from death: "כִּי חִלַּצְתָּ נַפְשִׁי מִמָּוֶת". In Psalm 118, he praises HaShem for saving him: "וְלַמָּוֶת לֹא נְתָנָנִי" (118:18).

Praise and Thanksgiving

Hallel divides into two very uneven units, with Chapters 113-117 constituting praise (הלל) and Chapter 118 comprising thanksgiving (הודאה).

  • Praise (Chapters 113-117)
    • Praise (113-114)
    • Request (115-116)
    • Praise (117)
  • Thanksgiving (118)
    • Thanksgiving – "הוֹדוּ לַי"י כִּי טוֹב"
    • Request – "אָנָּא י"י הוֹשִׁיעָה נָא"
    • Thanksgiving – "הוֹדוּ לַי"י כִּי טוֹב"

DIVIDING HALLEL AT THE SEDER

It is very likely that Hallel was the core text in the Haggadah. The Tosefta (Pesachim 10:8) records that the first paragraph of the Hallel (Tehillim, chapter 113) is read before the meal, and the remaining chapters (Tehillim chapters 114-118) are recited after the meal. The Mishnah (Pesachim 10:6) quotes that Beis Shammai followed the Tosefta, and said only to recite the first paragraph before the meal, while Beis Hillel said that one is recite two paragraphs (Tehillim, chapters 113,114) before the meal.

Why is the Hallel split up? One answer (from the Netziv) is that dividing the Hallel gives a framework to the meal to make the meal festive.

A second answer (in Kahti, commentary on the Mishnah Pesachim 10:6) is that we do not recite the entire Hallel in order that the children will not fall asleep, as presumably they should stay up at least until eating the matzah. According to this idea, Beis Shammai then says to recite the minimum of just one paragraph, while Beis Hillel says to add the second paragraph since it refers to the exodus from Egypt. (In the Tosefta 10:9, Beis Shammai explain that the second paragraph is not recited since the exodus did not occur yet, but as Beis Hillel points out this is a difficult argument.) While it does not seem that it takes so much time to recite the entire Hallel, this fear of the children falling asleep appears in the following Tosefta (10:9), which records that we steal/ grab matzah in order that the children will not fall asleep. This idea accords better with the idea that Maggid section was recited after the eating since then Hallel was the only thing recited before eating, as opposed today, where the Hallel is relatively short in comparison to the Maggid section, see our "Introduction to the Haggadah" and our discussion, "Mah nishtanah: Who says the mah nishtanah?"

Encyclopedia Talmudit (Hallel, 9:398) quotes a third reason from the Levush for splitting the Hallel that the first chapters relate to the Exodus while the last chapters relate to the future redemption. Rav Soloveitchik (2005, pp. 41-45) develops this idea by noting the difference between the chapters of Hallel. The first chapters are praises of G-d, while the last chapters have praise and also requests, as they refer to our dire straits. Thus, he suggests that we say the first two chapters since after the Maggid it is like we have left Egypt, and hence everything is perfect so we just have praise. However, after the meal, we return to our normal existence with its different troubles, and hence we have praise but also request for G-d to help us.

Maybe one can extend Rav Soloveitchik's idea to explain the argument between Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel. The first chapter has many praises of G-d. The second chapter refers to the miracles by the exodus, but it does not explicitly refer to praises of G-d. Thus, maybe Beis Shammai said only to recite the first chapter since it has the explicit praises of G-d, while Beis Hillel argued that even if the second paragraph does not have explicit praises of G-d still since it refers to the exodus, it too should be recited before the meal.

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN HALLEL ALL-YEAR AND BY THE SEDER

In addition to the division of the Hallel by the Seder, there are two other differences between the Hallel by the Seder and the Hallel we recite all year long.

One difference is that all year long we stand by the Hallel, but at the Seder we sit down. The Beis Yosef (end of 422, katuv) quotes from the Shibolei ha-Leket (Rome, 13th century) three reasons for sitting by the Seder. One, we sit because the Hallel is divided, two, if we would stand and hold the wine by the first two paragraphs, we might spill the wine, and three, since there is a law to recline by the Seder, we do not stand by the Hallel. (This last reason is mentioned by the Mishnah Berurah 480:1.) More likely, the requirement to stand by Hallel was a later development in the synagogue, and the old custom of sitting remained by the Seder.

The second difference is that even though we recite a full Hallel by the Seder, we do not recite a blessing before reciting the Hallel, either by the first two chapters or by the remaining chapters. This non-recitation of a blessing accords with the Mishnah (Pesachim 10:6) which does not mention making any blessing. Also, when the Talmud (Erechin 10b) discusses on which days one recites a full Hallel, there is no mention of Hallel on the night of Pesach, which implies that this Hallel is different than the other Hallels throughout the year. However, the Tosefta (Sukkot 4:2) includes the reciting of Hallel on the night of Pesach when gives a list of days when Hallel is recited. The implication of this Tosefta is that Hallel on the night of Pesach is similar to the Hallel all year round, and then a blessing would be recited, though this is not recorded in the Tosefta. Another source that indicates that a blessing should or could be said is in Masechet Soferim (20:9) which records that one should recite the blessing in the synagogue and then one would not have to recite the blessing at home. In addition, there are some Medieval commentators (see Tur, 473, and Encyclopedia Talmudit, vol. 9, p. 421) who claim that a person should make either one or two blessings by the Hallel by the Seder.

However, Rav Hai Gaon categorically stated that one is not to make any blessings on the Hallel (see Goldsmith, 1999, p. 81). Furthermore, Goldschmidt (1960, p. 56) notes that no blessing on Hallel has been found in any Haggadah from the time of the Geonim, including documents found in the Geniza. The Bet Yosef (Orah Chayyim 473, be-inyan) notes that the Ran (Pesachim p. 26 in pages of the Rif, mai birkat shir) thoroughly discussed the question of whether one is to recite a blessing on the Hallel, but R. Yosef Caro thought that there was no need to review this question since everybody's custom was not to recite a blessing.

Why do we not make a blessing prior to reciting Hallel by the Seder? Rav Hai Gaon wrote that Hallel by the Seder is different since it is a song. The idea being is that once a person feels that he has left Egypt, then naturally he/ she will come to praise G-d. This differs from the usual Hallel, where Chazal instituted the reciting of Hallel. In the case of Hallel by the Seder, the blessing would interfere with the natural impulse to recite Hallel, and hence this could be the reason why the blessing was not instituted.

More in this printout

View the whole printout