Skip to content
Parsha Pages

HaShem Hu Ha'Elokim" During the Yom Kippur Service

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Based essay by Rabbi Chaim Jachter

Conclusion of Yom Kippur

It is the climax of an incredible day, which reenacts the climax of an incredible event. Both Ashkenazic and Sephardic Jews end Yom Kippur with a recital of "HaShem Hu Ha'Elokim" multiple times, following the precedent set by the northern Bnei Yisrael at Har HaCarmel (Melachim I 18:39). Although this practice is not mentioned in the Gemara, it is mentioned by Tosafot (Berachot 34a s.v. Psuka).

Explanation of the Practice

The parallel between the culmination of Yorn Kippur and the event at Har HaCarmel seems at first to be most appropriate. At Har HaCarmel, the Bnei Yisrael initially are "Posechim Al Shnei HaSe'iftm," "dancing between two opinions," (Melachim I 18:21) unsure and tottering between commitment to HaShem and devotion to idolatry. However, at the conclusion of this event, Am Yisrael is fully convinced of HaShem, and expresses full Emunah by twice proclaiming "HaShem Hu HaEloki111," "HaShem is the God" (Melachim I 18:39).

Hopefully, the intense twenty-five hour deep spiritual immersion of Yom Kippur brings about a similar transformation. We may have entered the holy day struggling with dual spiritual loyalties, but emerge at its conclusion fully committed to HaShem!

Moreover, the parallel is enhanced if one assumes, as does the Malbim (Melachlm I 18:41), that the Bnei Yisrael at Har HaCarmel fast as a plea for rain. Eliyahu HaNavi then instructs them to eat and drink. We, similarly, shortly after proclaiming "HaShem Hu Ha'Elokim," proceed to breakfast.

Noting a Problem with the Practice

However, there is a problem with invoking and reenacting the emotional culmination of the Har HaCarmel experience. As is evident from the opening of Melachim I 19, the impact of the events at Har HaCarmel on Am Yisrael is shockingly fleeting. If so, why would we wish to invoke this admittedly extraordinary, yet, in terms of long-term impact, exceedingly limited event?

Tikkun of Mistakes of Prior Generations

Our suggested answer is based on a Kabbalistic idea that finds expression quite a number of times throughout the Tanach- the concept of Tikkun, a later generation's ability to correct the mistakes of an earlier generation. We find this, for example, in Megillat Esther. Esther 9 states no less than three times that the Jews do not take from the spoils after attacking Haman's supporters.

One is left wondering why this fact is so strongly emphasized by Megillat Esther. An answer that is often given is based on the fact that the Jewish leaders of this war, Esther and Mordechai, are descendants of Sha'ul HaMelech (Esther 2:5, Megillah 13b and 16a). The fact that the army, under the auspices of Mordechai and Esther, does not take from the spoils of war serves to rectify Sha'ul HaMelech's sin oftaking from the spoils of war after his attack on Amaleik (Shemuel I 15:9).

Reparative Reenactment

We suggest that part of the reason why we reenact Har HaCarmel and repeat "HaShem Hu HaElokim" at the culmination of Yom Kippur, is to repair Am Yisrael's past mistake. At Har HaCarmel, the Bnei Yisrael's transformation hardly lasts, because little investment is put into the event. When one makes little investment in an activity, it will almost invariably lead to poor results. As the Gemara teaches "HaOmer Lo Yagati U'MatZflti Al Ta'amin," "If someone says, 'I have not toiled and I have nonetheless succeeded,' do not believe him"' (Megillah 6b).

However, one who makes a considerable investment is much more likely to succeed. "HaOmer Yagati U'Matzati, Ta'amin," "If someone says, 'I have toiled and I have succeeded,' believe him" (ibid.). For example, the first Luchot HaBrit, fashioned by HaShem, are destroyed shortly after Matan Torah. In contrast, the second set of Luchot, fashioned by Moshe Rabbeinu, withstand the test of time.

At Har HaCarmel, the Bnei Yisrael are passive observers; thus, the long-term impact of the event is minimal. By contrast, we invest tremendously into Yom Kippur, considering our preparation during the Aseret Yemei Teshuvah and Chodesh Elul (and even more so for Sephardic Jews who recite Selichot the forty days before Yorn Kippur).

Thus, our recitation of "HaShem Hu Ha'Elokim" at the end of Yom Kippur has the potential to repair the shortcomings of the "HaShem Hu Ha'Elokim" of Har HaCarmel. Our declaration, on the heels of significant and intense spiritual investment, has the potential to serve as the harbinger for genuine spiritual growth that will last a lifetime.

Conclusion

Our Tefillot are jam-packed with references to Tanach. Once we fully understand the Tanach we reference, our Tefillot can be exponentially enhanced. It is, to say at least, well wroth making the effort to investigate these references.

HaShem is God

Who you are...is God's gift to you...

Who you become is your gift to God...

More in this printout

View the whole printout