Kol Nidre
By Rabbi Joshua Flug
I. Intro-
The tradition of reciting Kol Nidre dates back at least to the time of R. Amram Gaon (d. 875). {1} Throughout the time of the Geonim and the Rishonim, it was considered a controversial tradition and only recited in certain places. In this shiur outline, we will present two basic approaches to understand the goal of Kol Nidre. Additionally, we will discuss why Kol Nidre was chosen to kickoff the Yom Kippur service. We will also provide some some scholarly articles regarding Kol Nidre.
II. The Classic Understanding of Kol Nidre
a. The text presented by R. Amram Gaon seems to be a form of hataras nedarim.
- R. Amram Gaon himself notes that the yeshivas of the time objected to the practice claiming it was a minhag shtus.
- Rabbeinu Asher (c. 1250-1327) notes that R. Natronai Gaon (9th century) also objected to the practice. {2}
b. Rabbeinu Tam (c.1100-1171) presents four objections to the practice: {3}
- The Gemara states that hataras nedarim requires either three people or one expert to function as a beis din. {4} At Kol Nidrei, there is no beis din set up.
- In order to perform hataras nedarim, the individual must present regret for the neder. {5} Kol Nidrei makes no mention of regret. [The current version of Kol Nidrei does mention regret, but earlier versions did not.]
- According to R. Huna, which is the normative opinion, one must specify the nedarim in order for hataras nedarim to be effective. {6}
- The Mishna states that you can't annul your own vows. {7} How then can does kol nidrei work for the chazzan? [In Tosafos, Nedarim 23b, this objection is slightly different. How does kol nidrei work for anyone if this is merely each person performing hataras nedarim for himself?]
c. There are two ways to defend these objections:
- Rabbeinu Asher defends these objections directly: {8}
- When hataras nedarim is recited, the rest of the congregation serves as the beis din for the individual reciting it.
- It is clear that at the beginning of Yom Kippur there is regret for nedarim that if not annulled will lead to punishment.
- The requirement to specify vows only applies in a situation where the beis din may discourage the petitioner from annulling his vow. However, on Yom Kippur, we are trying to undo any vows that were already violated and therefore, there is no reason to discourage annulment.
- Since there is a beis din, one is not annulling his own vows.
- R. Yosef ibn Chabib (Nimmukei Yosef 14th-15th century) notes that Kol Nidrei may not be a halachic annulment of vows.
- Ramban (1194-1270) writes that Kol Nidre only works for vows that were violated accidentally. {9}
- Nimmukei Yosef, without quoting Ramban, expands on this idea and explains that Kol Nidre is a tefillah that one should not violate nedarim that one has already taken and one should not receive punishment for nedarim that were violated. {10}
- This idea explains some of the peculiar language in the text of Kol Nidre as presented by R. Amram Gaon:
a. בכולם חזרנו ובאנו לפני אבינו שבשמים- This line does not appear in our Kol Nidre, but it highlights the idea that the purpose is to appear before G-d in dealing with one's nedarim. If this were the classic hataras nedarim, this idea would not be relevant.
b. The quotation of the verse