Rosh HaShana 4a-6b, Nedarim 3 discusses the commandment of bal teʼacher “not to delay.” The Gemara derives that the Torah specifies that it is prohibited to delay fulfillment of one's vow beyond a certain period. This prohibition applies not only to vowed sacrificial offerings, but also to several other obligations.
What is the source from Torah?
כִּי-תִדּר נֶדֶר לַה' אֱלֹקֶיךָ לֹא תְאַחֵר לְשַׁלְמוֹ כִּי-דָרֹשׁ יִדְרְשֶׁנּוּ ה' אֱלֹקֶיךָ מֵעִמָּךְ וְהָיָה בְךָ חֵטְא: (דברים כג, כב)
“When you make a vow to HaShem, your G-d, you should not delay in paying it since HaShem, your G-d will be sure to exact it from you, and you will have sinned.”
This verse teaches that a person who accepts upon himself to bring a sacrifice cannot postpone fulfilling his promise. This mitzvah, referred to by the Sages as bal teʼacher - "do not be late [in bringing your sacrifice]" - is followed by another pasuk (Devarim 23,24), that emphasizes the need for one to fulfill all promises that one makes as a positive commandment, including - according to Chaza”l - promises made to charity.
A Nedar (a vowed offering) and a Nedavah (donated offering) are subject to the prohibition against delaying. The following are included since they are given completely to HaShem with no part given even to the Kohanim: Value vows, erech vows, cherem vows and consecrations. Liable for delaying these items and not for delaying its substitute. There words refer to obligatory offerings which HaShem "demands of you” such as: chatos, ashamos, olos, shelamim. Words are extra, thus, available to include commitments that the Torah mentions elsewhere with the Divine name, such as: Tzedakah, maaser, and bechor offering. Since referred to elsewhere with the same word with respect to the poor, also included are: Leket, Peah and Shichchah. The sin will be only in the person if delayed and not in the offering (which does not become invalid).
כִּי-תִדּר נֶדֶר
לַה' אֱלֹקֶיךָ
לֹא תְאַחֵר לְשַׁלְמוֹ
כִּי-דָרֹשׁ יִדְרְשֶׁנּוּ
ה' אֱלֹקֶיךָ
מֵעִמָּךְ
וְהָיָה בְךָ חֵטְא
How long does a person have to carry out his/her obligations before being held liable for bal teʼacher? Regarding sacrifices, the generally accepted position is that a person has a full cycle of holidays – Pesach, Shavuos, and Sukkos - to bring the commitments that were made to the Bais haMikdash. Regarding charity, however, Rava teaches that it must be given immediately after the commitment is made. He explains that, unlike a sacrifice that must be brought to the Temple, poor people are always accessible.
Several positions exist in understanding Rava's teaching.
According to the Ri'f, the Ritva and others, Rava's halacha only applies when there are, in fact, poor people located in the vicinity. If no poor people were immediately available, the person would not have to search for a poor person until three festivals had passed.
The Rashba argues that there is no difference whether a deserving poor person is available or not. In either case there is an immediate mitzvas aseh a positive commandment - to find a poor person who will accept the charity. Nevertheless, no transgression of bal teʼacher, the negative commandment, will take place until after the cycle of holidays has passed. Rava's statement that poor people are readily available merely explains why the mitzvas aseh is immediately incumbent upon him.
The Ran explains that the year-long extension allowed to the person who takes upon himself the obligation of a korban only makes sense in the context of sacrifices that will be brought to the Temple, usually during one of the pilgrimage holidays. Rava teaches that this concept has no place in a discussion about charity; therefore, Tzedakah must be given immediately, and someone who does not do so both misses his opportunity to fulfill the positive command and also transgresses bal teʼacher.
Concept of Three Festivals
שָׁלוֹשׁ פְּעָמִים | בַּשָּׁנָה יֵרָאֶה כָל־זְכוּרְךָ אֶת־פְּנֵי | יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ בַּמָּקוֹם אֲשֶׁר יִבְחָר בְּחַג הַמַּצוֹת וּבְחַג הַשָּׁבָעוֹת וּבְחַג הַמֶּכּוֹת וְלֹא יֵרָאֶה אֶת־פְּנֵי יְהוָה רֵיקָם: (דברים טז, טז)
Since the Torah just discussed each of the three festivals, this verse only needed to state שלש פעמים three times, and the meaning would have been understood. Why did the Torah spell out the name of each festival? The apparent redundant mention of each festival's name is teaching that one is liable for delaying fulfilling his “vows” (offerings and monetary) only after all three festivals have passed.
Halacha – bal te'acher
Rambam (Hilchos Pesulei ha'Mukdashim 14:13): It is a Mitzvas Aseh to fulfill Nedarim, Nedavos and other obligations to pay Erchin, Damim, Ma'aseros and Matanos Aniyim at the first Regel. We learn from "U'Vosa Shamah; Va'Haveisem Shamah". When you come to Yerushalayim for the Regel, you must bring all your obligations. If he did not bring his obligation at the time of the Regel, he was Mevatel the Aseh. If three Regalim passed and he did not offer the Korbanos or pay the money he transgressed "Lo Se'acher Leshalmo". There are no lashed for this for there is no action.
Vows of charity
“With your mouth,” refers to tzedaka. Rava said: Regarding Tzedakah one is liable [for delaying the fulfillment of a vow] immediately. Why? Because poor people are present [who need the money.]
Based on this Gemara, Rambam writes: A Tzedakah pledge is a form of a vow, therefore if one vows to give a selah to Tzedakah or if he commits to give a particular coin to Tzedakah he is obligated to give the pledged money to the poor immediately. If he delays giving the money he violates the prohibition of בל תאחר since he has the ability to give the money and poor people are present. If, however, poor people are not present one should set aside the money until a poor person is available. This ruling is cited by Shulchan Aruch.
Rav Betzalel Stern questions whether one violates בל תאחר every day he does not fulfill his pledge or whether he violates the prohibition only once and the violation is ongoing. His conclusion is that once a poor person comes to collect the money and the donor does not fulfill his vow, he violates the prohibition and that violation continues until he fulfills his vow. There is a dispute whether the new refusal constitutes a new violation or a continuation of the original violation if, after refusing to give Tzedakah to the first poor person, he subsequently refuses to fulfill his vow when a second and third poor person asks for the money.
Rav Moshe Isserles, the Rema, qualifies this ruling and states that it applies only when the donor is going to distribute the money to the poor himself. If, however, the pledge was made to a shul or other charitable organization, one does not violate בל תאחר even if poor people are present, until the Gabbai Tzedakah claims the money. Only when the Gabbai Tzedakah claims the money and the donor refuses to fulfill his vow is the prohibition violated. Furthermore, if the Gabbai Tzedakah is unaware of the pledge the donor is obligated to inform him that a pledge was made so that he will be able to claim the money.
Seudas Shabbos
Chofetz Chaim states that if one has a poor guest to his home for the Shabbos meal, one is obligated to eat immediately upon returning from shuel to avoid bal teacher. One should not delay by saying Shalom Aleichem or singing since the meal given to the poor is Tzedakah. Thus, one cannot tarry or stall at all. The Chofetz Chaim himself was accustomed when he had poor guests, to say Shalom Aleichem during the meal. Further, he would not stay longer in shuel, even to engage in Divrei Torah.
“With your mouth” (Devarim 23,24) refers to Tzedakah
Apparently upon death one cannot take anything with him except acts of Mitzvos, good deeds and Tzedakah. A parable of understanding: When one wishes to move across a border, one does not have permission to take any wealth or property. Thus, a person would transfer the value to a precious stone and swallow it. After crossing the border, the person would spit up the stone. So a person crosses the border of death one can only take acts that can be swallowed. Thus, Lavan checked the mouth of Yaacov. (Orach Yesharim)
AGADAH (Rosh HaShana 6b): One's wife will not die for the sin of "BAL TE'ACHER" (dafyomi.co.il)
QUESTION: The Gemara concludes that the verse, "v'Hayah Becha Chet" -- "It shall be a sin for you" (Devarim 23:22), teaches that the prohibition of Bal Te'acher (delaying the fulfillment of a Neder) affects only the transgressor and not his wife.
TOSFOS (DH Ela Im Ken) adds that when the Gemara in Shabbos (32b) says that one's wife may be punished if he fails to fulfill his Neder, it refers only to a situation in which the husband never fulfills his Neder. If he eventually fulfills it, his wife will not be punished for his delay.
The Midrash relates that Rachel Imenu died on the way to Eretz Yisrael because Yaacov Avinu delayed the fulfillment of his pledge to bring a libation of oil (Nisuch Shemen) to the Mizbe'ach in Beis-El. Many years earlier, when he left Eretz Yisrael to travel to the house of Lavan, he vowed to offer a libation on the Mizbe'ach upon his return (Bereishis Rabah 81:2; see also Rashi to Bereishis 35:1). Yaacov Avinu eventually fulfilled his Neder (before Rachel died), as the Torah relates (Bereishis 35:6-7).
The Midrash clearly implies that Yaacov Avinu's wife died as a result of his transgression of Bal Te'acher, even though he eventually fulfilled his Neder. How is the Midrash to be reconciled with the Gemara here?
(KOHELES YAACOV (Rav Algazi); CHIDA in NITZOTZEI OROS to the Zohar loc cit.)ANSWERS:
(a) The PERASHAS DERACHIM (Derush #3, DH uva'Zeh Yuvan) explains that the Midrash indeed argues with the Gemara (see TOSFOS DH mid'Ben, and SEFAS EMES here). The Tana'im of the Midrash maintain that transgressing the prohibition of Bal Te'acher does affect one's wife, as the Midrash states explicitly (in Vayikra Rabah loc cit.): "One who vows and delays his vow buries his wife."
(b) The KLI CHEMDAH (beginning of VaYishlach) suggests that the Midrash does not argue with the Gemara. Rather, Rachel Imenu died during childbirth, a life-threatening condition (as the Gemara mentions in Shabbos 32a). Since the attribute of strict justice is manifest at life-threatening moments, Rachel was unprotected from the ramifications of her husband's transgression of Bal Te'acher. Under normal circumstances, however, one's wife is not punished for her husband's sin of Bal Te'acher alone. (The Kli Chemdah offers another, intricate answer "Pilpul".)
(c) An original solution may be suggested based on the words of the MESHECH CHOCHMAH (VaYetzei 31:13; see also Meshech Chochmah to Vayishlach 35:8). In his Neder (Bereishis 28:22), Yaacov Avinu promised that upon his safe return he would offer Nesachim on the same "Matzeivah" that he had set up on his way to Lavan. When he finally returned, however, HaShem told him to erect a new "Mizbe'ach" and not to use the original Matzeivah (Bereishis 35:1 and 7).
The Torah forbids making a Matzeivah today because it is something which HaShem "has come to despise" (Devarim 16:22). Rashi explains that although the Avos built Matzeivos and brought offerings upon them, the practice became despicable to HaShem when the idol-worshippers imitated the practice and adopted it for the service of their idols. Consequently, one may make only a Mizbe'ach and not a Matzeivah. A Mizbe'ach is comprised of several stones, while a Matzeivah is comprised of a single stone.
Perhaps the idolaters adopted the practice of building a Matzeivah after they saw Yaacov build his Matzeivah for HaShem when he was on his way to the house of Lavan. This explains why Yaacov Avinu was permitted to make a Matzeivah when he left Eretz Yisrael but he was not permitted to use it upon his return. By the time he returned 22 years later, the building of Matzeivos had become a common practice among idolaters. (The verse which mentions the building of a Matzeivah in the context of Yaacov's return is merely a flashback to Yaacov's initial journey to Lavan; see Ramban and Seforno there.)
According to this explanation, one may propose that had Yaacov Avinu returned earlier to fulfill his Neder he might have been able to pour oil on the Matzeivah, because the idolaters had not yet adopted the practice. In the time that he delayed, the idolaters began to use Matzeivos in their idol-worship, and, as a result, he was unable to fulfill his Neder in its entirety (since he could not make a Matzeivah). His wife was punished not because he delayed his Neder, but because he was unable to fulfill it in its entirety.