Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Smoking Pipes: Trapping with Virtual Walls on Yom Tov

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Yom Tov

The Bergers went to the African savannas for Pesach (see Excitement in Halacha: Buffalo Wings). Berel Berger and his children joined their relatives on their exotic adventure, and to complete a minyan. They set up camp, and surrounded it with a moat, for protection from wild animals.

There were torrential downpours throughout Chol HaMoed, and by the second days of Yom Tov, the moat was filled with water.

"Tatty, the animals might swim across the moat," Shmuli said worriedly. "How will we be protected from animals?"

"You have an important point, Shmuli," stated Rabbi Berger. "I am right now setting up my newest gadget. I am attaching pipes with holes along them to channel the smoke from the campfires that we have constantly burning. They will appear to the animals as walls."

On Yom Tov morning, Goldy awoke early and peeked out of the smoke walls, noticing a group of ostriches drinking from the moat. Suddenly, as the sun started to rise, the ostriches broke into a dance!

Shmuli awoke from the wild bird entertainment.

While Goldy was mesmerized, Shmuli noticed a pack of hyenas in the distance.

They quickly ran over to Rabbi Berger who was getting ready with the boys to daven.

"Can we put the smoke walls around the ostriches to protect them from the hyenas?" Shmuli asked.

Points to Ponder: "Is it considered Trapping on Yom Tov to surround the ostriches within the virtual walls?" Yehoshua asked.

"Maybe, since they are technically able to leave the trap easily, it should be permitted to purposely trap them?1" suggested Yossi.

"According to the mind of an ostrich, it can't leave the area, so probably it is considered the Melacha of Trapping,2" argued Baruch.

"Since the animal can't see any escape route, trapping it in its mind should be prohibited,3" explained Rabbi Berger.

"Is it proper to try to save the ostriches from being eaten?" asked Binyamin.

Conclusion: "Hashem created the animals to eat each other,4" concluded Rabbi Berger. "Also, if we protect the ostriches this might be considered tzaar baalei chayim for the hyenas."

Just then, the Bergers glanced back, and they saw the ostriches escaping from the hyenas at full speed!

  1. ביאור הלכה על שכז:ד ד"ה ובלבד; חשוקי חמד שבת קו:
  2. ד"ה צבי שנכנס לבית; תורת המלאכות מלאכת צד הארה לד
  3. מגדל דויד מלאכת צד הארה קכד, וגב
  4. משנה ברורה שכז:יח; אג"ח רסו:ב; חשוקי חמד ב"מ פה: ד"ה הואיל ומרחם נרחם עליה; בן יהוידע ב"מ פה:; חידושי מהריעבץ; חכם סופר בהלויתו; עיין כוכבי אור קמג; אור יהל חלק א' עמ' קסד'-קע'; מכתב מאליהו ג' עמ' 103

Written by: Simcha Zisel Nakdimen | Editing by: Rabbi Benzion Weissberger | Illustrated by: Yosef Kadish Greenburg | Reviewed by: Rabbi Meir Platnick

More in this printout

View the whole printout