THE LAWS OF MELACHAH ON CHOL HAMOED
Five general categories of permitted melachos
- OCHEL NEFESH – FOOD RELATED PURPOSES
- TZORECH HAMOED – FESTIVAL REQUIREMENT
- DAVAR HAOVED – AVOIDING LOSS OR DAMAGE
- TZORCHEI RABIM – COMMUNITY NEEDS
- POEL SHE'EIN LO MAH LE'ECHOL – A LABOURER WHO DOES NOT HAVE SUFFICIENT INCOME FOR YOM TOV FOOD
Fishing in order to eat the fish on Chol haMoed or Yom Tov is permitted on Chol haMoed ¹. However, fishing for leisure is prohibited according to the majority of the Poskim ².
It is permitted to listen to music, and to play music on Chol haMoed including Chol haMoed Pesach (even for those that keep the first half of sefira) ³. New suits and clothing may be worn as well ⁴.
Working on Chol haMoed is only permitted under specific circumstances, eg in case of ‘loss'. The main purpose of the Chol haMoed work restrictions was to allow more time to learn. ⁵
Included in the leniency of physical needs on Chol haMoed, Chazal permitted for women melachos relating to the application of cosmetics and the like. Having a wig professionally set is a machlokes haposkim ⁶.
When on Chol haMoed outings to a farm, zoo etc, it is forbidden to feed the animals any chometz. Feeding animals is considered a hanaha (benefit), and is forbidden on Pesach, even if both the chometz and the animal are the property of a non-Jew.
The consensus of many poskim is that writing (i.e. typing) on a computer is not considered writing for purposes of the prohibition of writing on Chol haMoed ⁷. Although with regard to Shabbos this is definitely considered writing, HoRav Wosner explains that Chol ha-Moed is different because it does not involve any effort. ⁸
However, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach ⁹ has an issue with writing on a computer since it involves saving information on the hard drive which is considered an act of boneh.¹⁰ However, printing from a computer is prohibited according to numerous poskim since the finished product is akin to a ma'ase uman.¹¹ (see footnote). Obviously where a maʼase uman is permitted, this is also permitted. Casual writing is considered a ma'ase hedyot. This is permitted l'tzorach hamoed as noted above.
Three types of activities prohibited on Chol HaMoed (so that one does not appear unkempt and unclean when entering the Tom Tov.) ¹²
- LAUNDERING;
- HAIRCUTTING (including shaving); and
- CUTTING ONE'S NAILS.
Laundering
Washing a sheitel is prohibited as it is considered a begged (piece of clothing) and therefore included in the laundering prohibition. Some Poskim allow setting a sheitel on chol hamoed when it is done l'tzorech haMoed. Others disagree.¹³ Therefore it is preferable to prepare it before Yom Tov.
Most Poskim rule that the leniency of laundering when one has "only piece of a particular clothing" does not apply nowadays (except for clothing made form linen).¹⁴
Bath Towels may not be washed
Hand towels may be washed once one's entire supply has been finished.
Rav Wosner permits washing tablecloths once one's entire supply has been finished. Other Poskim are more machmir. See Rivevos Efraim 429: 1 for a discussion about using arava of the lulav for hoshana banging.
"Spot cleaning" a stain on one's clothing is permitted according to many Poskim if it may be removed (with a little water).¹⁵ A 'dry stain' which can be brushed off with a brush may be removed.
One may wash on Chol haMoed a stain which may leave a permanent mark on clothing if left until after haMoed.
Children's clothing should be washed prior to Yom Tov. However, since children dirty their clothing frequently, Chazal permitted laundering their clothing once their supply of clean clothing is insufficient.
One is not obligated to purchase extra children's clothing in order to avoid or minimize laundering their clothing on Chol haMoed.¹⁶
When going away for Yom Tov one should endeavor to pack as much children's clothing as possible in order to minimize laundering their clothing on Chol haMoed.¹⁷
Chol haMoed - General
One may not instruct a non-Jew to perform a melocho which is forbidden for a Jew. ¹⁸
Halochos of muktzeh do not apply on Chol haMoed. ¹⁹
It is permitted to listen to music, and to play music on Chol HaMoed including Chol HaMoed Pesach.
General checkups at a dentist or eye doctor should not be scheduled during Chol haMoed.
Simcha and Wine on Chol haMoed: The mitzvah of 'simcha' is applicable to Chol haMoed as well (Rambam Hill Yom Tov 6). From the Shulchan Aruch and Mishna Berura it seems that drinking a reviis of wine is the method to perform this mitzvah. ²⁰ This is also the opinion of Rav M Feinstein and Rav Y S Elyashiv. ²¹ Rav M Feinstein adds that one is not yotzei with grape juice, while Rav Elyashiv permits using grape juice as long as some wine is added to make it mesame'ach as a result of the alcohol. Rav M Sternbauch disagrees and rules that there is no obligation to drink wine on Chol haMoed. ²²
ma'ase hedyot "simple unskilled" workma'ase uman "skilled" workPermitted if deliberately scheduled on Chol haMoed?minor effortexcessive effortminor effortexcessive effortOchel NefeshPermittedPermittedPermittedPermittedyesTzorech haMoedPermittedProhibitedProhibitedProhibitednoDavor haOvedminimum lossPermittedProhibitedProhibitedProhibitednosubstantial lossPermittedPermittedPermittedPermittedTzorchei Rabimfor Yom TovProhibitedProhibitedPermittedPermittedyesfor after Yom TovPermittedPermittedProhibitedProhibitedPoel She'ein Lo Mah Le'echolPermittedPermittedPermittedPermittedyesNotes:
- О.С. 533:4
- Rav M Feinstein permits (and advises that preferable to eat the fish on Chol haMoed or Yom Tov (and not freeze for afterwards) while the majority of Poskim prohibit. See Chol haMoed Kehilchoso 7:21.
- Pri Megodim (493 MZ 2) forbids dancing. Common custom is to permit listening to music (see Rav Chaim Kanievsky in sefer Dole UMashke p 193 cites the reason since there is no aveilus on Chol haMoed). Rav Y D Harfenes (Mekadesh Yisroel -Sefira siman 68) however is hesitant to permit dancing as well.
- Rav Y D Harfenes in Mekadesh Yisroel -Sefira siman 68.
- Yerushalmi quoted in Mishneh Berurah Hil Chol haMoed 530:2.
- Rav M Feinstein prohibits while Rav M Stern permits.
- Shu't Be'er Moshe (7:39), and Shu't Shevet Ha-Kehasi (1:169), who are both lenient, arguing that the digital display of a computer is not considered writing since a) it is not miskayem and b) it is not ink on paper rather a series of led lights.
- Shu't Shevet HaLevi (6:37 sec. 1)
- See Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchoso 66
- Where required for the moed, or a davrr haoved it would be permitted.
- This question depends on the machlokes Acharonim whether a ma'ase uman is defined by the effort / action involved or by the finished product. A printed page is actioned by a simple push of a button, but it produces a skilled work.
- From a pure melocho perspective, these activities would have been permitted (as they fall into one of the permitted categories listed below - they may be considered TZORECH HAMOED, a festival need) were it not for Chazal's additional prohibition.
- Rav Moshe Feinstein prohibits while Rav M Stern permits.
- See Mishneh Berurah
- Rav Wosner and Rav M Feinstein permit this.
- Chut Shoni Chol haMoed p239
- Rav Moshe Stern quoted in ShSh"K 66 fn 255 rules that one must take 'all' their clothing, but Rav M Feinstein is lenient that where there is much tirche involved it is not required.
- O.C. 543:1
- Exception for benefitting from the sukka or its decorations which is a different type of muktzeh and involves the use of an item rather than merely moving it.
- See O.C. 529 and Biur Halocho sv keitzad.
- Cited in Shvus Yitzchok.
- Teshuvos Vehanogos 5:153. He explains that the simcha of wine is that it be drunk during a meal. Since there is no obligation to have a meal on Chol haMoed, there cannot be an obligation of simcha with wine.