By Rabbi Joshua Flug
I. Introduction
This shiur outline will discuss the minhag of reciting Yizkor on the yamim tovim. We will address the following:
- The background and source for the minhag.
- The reason why people not reciting Yizkor exit the room.
- The purpose of the Yizkor candle and whether one may light it on Yom Tov.
- A few derasha ideas relating to Yizkor.
II. Background
- Can we help atone for those who are deceased?
- The Midrash states that the eglah arufah process can even help atone for those who lived through yetzias Mitzrayim. (Sifrei end of Parshas Shoftim)
- The Tanchuma Chadash (a later addition to the Tanchuma) quotes the above Midrash as a source for reciting Yizkor and giving tzedakah on Yom Kippur. There is a particular emphasis on giving tzedakah. (Tanchuma Chadash, HaAzinu siman 1)
- In the shiur outline on Mourner's Kaddish, we noted a general discussion about the idea of the living providing atonement for the deceased:
- The Gemara (Sanhedin 104a) states that the good deeds of a child can help a parent but not vice versa.
- R. Shmuel Eidels (Maharsha, 1555-1631) explains that the parent deserves some credit for every good deed that the child does, even if the parent was a רשע. (Sanhedrin 104a)
- Rabbeinu Bachya ben Asher (1255-1340) writes that in general, someone who is alive can do something on behalf of someone who has died and this is the basis for giving tzedakah or saying Kaddish on behalf of someone else. There is an additional benefit of the child doing this as it allows the deceased to reap the rewards for raising children properly. (Shoftim 21,5)
- The question of whether the deceased can receive benefits after death is the subject of debate:
- Maharam Chalava (c. 1290-1370) writes that once someone dies, they generally can no longer receive any merits. The one exception to this rule is a child's good deeds because those are indicative of the parent's good deeds in raising the child and therefore count retroactively towards the parent, similar to someone who pledged money during their lifetime that wasn't paid until after death. (Shu't siman 17)
- R. Elazar of Worms (c. 1176-1238) writes that we pledge tzedakah on behalf of people who are deceased because we believe that God will look at this action and judge if the deceased would have given this tzedakah if he were still alive and had the means. (Sefer Rokeach siman 217)
- R. Yehuda of Regensburg (R. Yehuda HeChasid 1140-1217) quotes the Midrash as a source that tzedakah given on behalf of the deceased can help after death, but seems to limit it to tzedakah, not other acts. (Sefer Chasidim sim 170)
- R. Tzidkiyah HaRofei (c. 1210-1280) presents a view that the Midrash was dealing specifically about atonement for murder and tzedakah won't help. (Shivli haLekach siman 81)
- As noted by R. Elazar of Worms, Yom Kippur was traditionally the day to give tzedakah on behalf of the deceased:
- R. Aharon HaKohen of Lunil (13th-14th century) presents the ideas of the Midrash and the Tanchuma Chadash (which he presents as the Yerushalmi) in explaining why we recite Yizkor on Yom Kippur. He notes that tzedakah has a particularly strong influence when we are dealing with atonement. (Ourchos haChaim Hil. Yom haKippurim siman 34)
- Another reason to mention the deceased on Yom Kippur is to humble the yetzer harah.
- The idea of reciting Yizkor is codified by Mordechai (c. 1250-1298) (Yuma siman 727) and subsequently by Rama (1520-1572) (O.Ch. 621,6)
- Yizkor on Yom Tov:
- The sources presented above that discuss reciting Yizkor, all discuss reciting it on Yom Kippur. There is no mention of Yizkor or collecting tzedakah for this purpose on Yom Tov.
- R. Aharon HaKohen's second reason for reciting Yizkor seems to be limited to Yom Kippur.
- Rabbeinu Simcha (d. 1105) writes that one should collect tzedakah on the last day of each Yom Tov because we read the parsha of tzedakah on those days, specifically איש כמתנת ידו. However, one should not mention the deceased on Yom Tov because Yom Tov is a day of simcha and we shouldn't remind ourselves of the deceased on Yom Tov. The only day to give tzedakah to atone for the deceased is Yom Kippur. (Machzor Vitry seder Hag Shavuos)
- The earliest mention in classic halachic literature of Yizkor on yamim tovim is by R. Mordechai Yoffe (c. 1530-1612). He writes that since we read about tzedakah on Yom Tov, it is appropriate to give tzedakah, and since we are giving tzedakah, we recite Yizkor so that the deceased can receive atonement from our tzedakah. (Luvash O.Ch. 490,9)
- In the 17th and 18th centuries, recitation of Yizkor on Yom Tov was known as a Polish minhag:
- R. Tzvi Hirsch Koidenover (17th century) identifies the minhag to recite Yizkor on Yom Tov as a Polish minhag. He suggests that the reason for it is a remembrance for the Beis HaMikdash. When the Beis HaMikdash was standing, the deceased would all visit the מקדש של מעלה. Nowadays, we mention the deceased so that they can partake of the Yom Tov festivities and serve as a zechus for us. (Kav haYashar Chapter 86)
- R. Ya'akov Emden (1697-1776) also identifies the minhag to recite Yizkor on Yom Tov as a Polish minhag. (Siddur Yaveetz Acharon shel Pesach)
- It seems from both of these comments that the reason why it is not a problem to invoke the memory of the deceased on Yom Tov is because we are not focused on them, but rather on how their zechusim can help us. Another answer to this question will be presented in the next section.
III. The minhag that those who aren't reciting Yizkor exit
- R. Ephraim Z. Margulies (1762-1828) presents two reasons for leaving: (Shaarei Efraim 10,35)
- The Gemara (Berachos 20b) states that a ba'al keri, who can't recite Kerias Sh'ma, should think about it while everyone else is reciting so that he is not sitting idly while everyone else is reciting Sh'ma. R. Margulies suggests that we don't want those who don't have anyone for whom to recite Yizkor to sit idly and therefore, they leave.
- The Gemara (Yevamos 106a) relates a story about a yavam who didn't want to perform chalitza and was playing games with Abaye. Abaye asked him if his parents were in the city. He responded positively and the next time Abaye looked at them, they died. R. Margulies understands that the parents died from ayin harah. When the yavam said that his parents were alive, it created some sort of envy and this is what caused them to die. We don't want this to happen when there are people in shul sitting idly while others are reciting Yizkor.
- R. Moshe Mordechai Epstein (1866-1933) notes that if there is a chasan in the room, we don't recite hazkaras neshamos because we don't want to ruin his simcha. In reality, the same should apply to Yizkor on Yom Tov. We shouldn't recite it because it will ruin simchas Yom Tov. However, since it provides a degree of comfort to those who recite Yizkor and actually brings them simchas Yom Tov, we recite it and ask those who are going to be negatively affected by its recitation to leave. (Levush Mordechai Bava Kama, beginning)
IV. Yizkor Candles
- Kol Bo (14th century) states that on Yom Kippur, each person should have a candle next to their seat. He presents a number of reasons for this: (Kol Bo siman 68)
- Because a candle is a sign of atonement as the candle represents the neshama and on Yom Kippur, we try to atone for the deceased.
- Because each person needs his own light.
- Because the lights enhance the honor of the shul.
- Because each person needs a light that was lit for the entire day in order to recite Havdalah.
- While this isn't really an additional reason, Kol Bo mentions that there was a guard in the shul to make sure that a fire didn't break out from the candles. This should be a consideration in determining where to light the Yizkor lights.
- Rama records the minhag to light extra candles in shul and mentions the first reason-to honor the deceased. (O.Ch. 610,4)
- R. Yechiel M. Tukaczinski (1872-1955) writes that one should specifically light the Yizkor candles in shul and this is especially the case on Yom Tov.. (Gesher haChaim 31,5)
- Lighting a Yizkor candle on Yom Tov
- The Talmud Yerushalmi (Beiah 5,2) quotes a dispute as to whether it is permissible to light a נר של אבטלה a candle that has no purpose, on Yom Tov.
- Shulchan Aruch rules that it is prohibited to light such a candle, but the candles lit in shul are not considered נר של אבטלה because they enhance the shul. (O.Ch. 514,5)
- R. Avraham S.B. Sofer (1815-1871) writes that one can justify the practice of lighting yahrtzeit candles (he does not mention Yizkor) on Yom Tov because they are being used to fulfill the mitzvah of kibbud av va'em and therefore serve a purpose. He recommends lighting it before Yom Tov, but if one forgot, or it blew out, one should light it in the shul because in the shul it's not considered a נר של אבטלה. (Kosev Sofer O.Ch. siman 65)
- Mishna Berurah writes that if one forgot to light the yahrtzeit candle before Yom Tov, one may light it in a place where one is eating, but it is preferable to light it in the shul.
- R. Yechiel M. Epstein (1829-1908) writes that even in shul, one should not light too many candles (ostensibly because at some point, it no longer enhances the shul). He writes that this becomes an issue on days when Yizkor is recited. (O.Ch. 514,19) His comments positively identify a minhag to light candles on days when Yizkor is recited, though he still considers them be נרות של אבטלה if they don't enhance the shul.
- Using Electric Lights for Yizkor Lights
- R. Tukaczinski writes that it is preferable to use olive oil, if not possible, the next best option is wax and if that's not possible, then an electric light may be used.
- R. Mordechai Ya'akov Breisch (1896-1977) writes that one should not use electric lights because of kabbalistic reasons. (Chelkas Yaacov 1,154)
- In many shuls there are yahrtzeit boards with electric lights next to each person's name that are turned on when a yahrtzeit is observed and on days when Yizkor is recited. The purpose of those lights is ostensibly to serve as the Yizkor light.
V. Selected derasha ideas
- R. Yitzchak Nussbaum (Warsaw, 1866-1942) delivered a derasha (available here) where he laments the fact that there are people who only come to shul on days when Yizkor is recited. He notes that by doing this, they are giving more value to the past than they are to the future. If they don't bring their children to shul on a regular basis, then they are sacrificing their future. (Hagos 32)
- R. Gedaliah Silverstone (1871-1944) was the Chief Rabbi of Washington DC in the early 20th century. Sometime between 1905 and 1915, he gave a derasha (available here) comparing Decoration Day (now called Memorial Day) in the U.S. to Yizkor. The American tradition is to lay flowers on the graves of those who served to defend the country. The Jewish tradition is also to lay flowers for those who sacrificed for the Torah, but a different kind of flower. We provide them with spiritual flowers, the tzedakah that we pledge on their behalf. (Peninim Yakarim chelk 1 page 5)