By Rabbi Joshua Flug
Introduction-This shiur outline will discuss the nature of Neilah and how it relates to the end of Yom Kippur
II. The Occasions in which Neilah is recited
- The Mishna states that there are three occasions which would allow the kohanim to duchen four times in one day, all due to the fact that there is Neilah: Those occasions are: Fast days, Yom Kippur and Ma'amados (just like the 24 mishmeros kehuna, there were twenty-four groups of Jews who stood over the korbanos and on their ma'amad, they would recite Neilah). {1}
- The Talmud Yerushalmi discusses what time one should recite neilah. This discussion gives us insight into what Neilah refers to: {2&3}
- According to Rav, it refers to נעילת שערי שמים.
- According to R. Yochanan, it refers to נעילת שערי היכל.
- The Yerushalmi contends that if it refers to נעילת שערי שמים, one can continue into the night, whereas the נעילת שערי היכל were during the day. Thus, Rav seems to hold that one can recite Neilah at night. The Yerushalmi questions this from a story involving Rav who was insistent on starting Neilah when the sun was at the tip of the trees (shortly before sundown). The Yerushalmi answers that Rav would start before sundown but continue into the night when the שערי שמים are closed.
- Rabbeinu Nissim (c. 1320-1380) has a different girsa in the Yerushalmi. According to his girsa, it is Shmuel, not R. Yochanan who disagrees with Rav. {4} This might be important when we see the Bavli.
- Why don't we recite Neilah on all fast days?
- The Gemara states that Tisha B'Av is not considered a "fast" for the purpose of reciting neilah. {5}
- Rabbeinu Nissim explains that we only recite Neilah for fasts that are for the purpose of tefillah. The public fasts that we observe are for the purpose of mourning. Furthermore, Rabbeinu Nissim writes that Neilah is reserved for fasts that are observed as days of extreme prayer (such as the last set of fasts for rain). If a public fast is declared, the first few fasts for that occasion don't warrant Neilah. {7}
- Rabbeinu Nissim's approach seems to be based on the comments of Rambam (1138-1204) regarding Neilah:
- Rambam writes that Neilah is a prayer whose purpose is to add further prayers to the fast day. {8}
- Rambam writes that Neilah is only recited in the last seven of the fasts for rain. {9}
- Rambam also notes that the public fasts observed to commemorate previous events don't involve teruah (a form of prayer reserved for emergencies) or Neilah. {10}
- Ritva (1250-1330) writes that Neilah is recited on all public fasts observed to deter a crisis. The reason why we don't recite Neilah when the rabbis declare a fast is that those who are fasting are not considered a tzibbur for this purpose and individuals who fast don't recite Neilah. {11}
- R. David Avudraham (14th century) writes that when Neilah is recited on a fast day, one adds vidui including מה אנו מה חיינו.
- The Gemara states that Tisha B'Av is not considered a "fast" for the purpose of reciting neilah. {5}
III. Neilah on Yom Kippur
- The Gemara states that if Yom Kippur occurs on Shabbos, one must mention Shabbos during Neilah
- This implies that the requirement to recite Neilah is inherent to Yom Kippur. [The Gemara uses the same language to explain why Al HaNissim is recited on Shabbos Chanukah at Mussaf.]
- The Gemara quotes a dispute between Rav and Shmuel regarding Neilah. According to Rav, it is an additional Amidah. According to Shmuel, it is the recitation of מה אנו מה חיינו (what we know as the unique parts of vidui found in Neilah). The Gemara disproves Shmuel's opinion from a Beraisa which discusses Neilah and whether the chasimah of the middle beracha relates to the kedushas hayom or to vidui. According to both opinions, there is an additional Amidah which is problematic for Shmuel. {14}
- Rashi (1040-1105) writes that the discussion about the closing of the beracha is limited to Neilah. In all other tefillos of Yom Kippur, the closing is focused on kedushas hayom, whereas at Neilah, one can/should add כי אתה סלחן לישראל וכו'. Rashi rejects a version of the Tosefta that it can be recited in any of the tefillos. {15
- R. Zerachiah HaLevi (Ba’al HaMaor, 12th century) writes that in the siddurim of the Geonim this chasima appears in the Amidah of Neilah but he has never seen it in practice. {16}
- Our practice is to use this chasimah in all Amidahs of Yom Kippur.
- The Proper Time to Recite Neilah
- As noted earlier, the Yerushalmi has a discussion of when Neilah should be recited.
- In the Bavli, the discussion doesn't appear explicitly but the Rishonim relate it to a discussion about using Neilah to exempt oneself from Ma'ariv. The Gemara quotes Rav as saying that one who recites Neilah is not required to recite Ma'ariv. The Gemara notes that Rav is following his own opinion that Neilah is a full Amidah. {17}
- Rabbeinu Asher (c. 1250-1327) notes that Rav is also following his opinion in the Yerushalmi that Neilah can be recited at night and notes that we don't follow Rav's opinion. Therefore, one must recite Neilah during the day and it cannot exempt Ma'ariv. {18}
- Rabbeinu Nissim also ties the Ma'ariv exemption to what time Neilah should be recited, but follows the opinion of Rav that one should start towards the end of the day and extend it into the night. {19}
- Shulchan Aruch rules that one should finish before shekiah. {20}
- Mishna Berurah notes that this really means the end of shekias hachamah which is tzeis hakochavim, as long as one starts before shekiah. He also quotes an opinion that one could extend past tzeis. {21}
- Rabbi Soloveitchik's analysis
- R. Yosef D. Soloveitchik (1903-1993) notes that the dispute between Rav and Shmuel regarding whether one recites an Amidah for Neilah is contingent on whether Neilah is an obligation to recite vidui or whether it's an obligation of tefillah. Nevertheless, even Rav agrees that there is no inherent obligation to recite another Amidah. Rather, it is the atonement of the day that triggers the obligation to pray. This is why the chasima of the beracha can supplant the kedushas hayom at Neilah. [The Rav doesn't address the fact that we use this chasima throughout Yom Kippur.]
- Since we follow the opinion of Rav, one must still figure out what type of tefillah it is: a request for forgiveness or a prayer of thanksgiving for our forgiveness. If it's the former, it makes sense that it should be completed before the end of the day. If it's the latter, one can add this prayer of thanksgiving after the day is completed. The conclusion of the Yerushalmi that one starts during the day and ends at night indicates that there is an element of bakasha as well as an element of hoda'ah. {22- Note that not all of the paragraphs are presented in the source sheet}
- Rabbi Soloveitchik also notes that Neilah doesn't exist in a vacuum, it is an added prayer, such that one who didn't recite any of the Amidahs on Yom Kippur cannot recite Neilah. He notes that his father, R. Moshe Soloveitchik suggested that maybe one cannot recite Neilah
even if one skipped a single prayer of Yom Kippur because without all of the prayers, Neilah cannot be considered “additional.” {23}
- There is a dispute regarding someone who missed Neilah and whether there is tashlumin after Yom Kippur:
- R. Menachem Azariah of Fano (1548-1620) writes that it is comparable to Mussaf which has no tashlumin. {24}
- R. Yosef Teomim (1727-1792) writes that there is tashlumin. {25}
- Rav Soloveitchik noted that since there is no inherent obligation to pray and it's only triggered because of the atonement, there is no tashlumin. {26} [He notes that although the Gemara mentions the obligation to include Shabbos in Neilah because there is an obligation to recite an extra Amidah, it doesn't mean that the obligation is inherent, but rather an observation based on the fact that there will always be an obligation to recite Neilah.]
IV. Neilah as the Chasima of the Judgment of Rosh HaShanah
- The Beraisa states that (according to R. Meir) people are judged on Rosh HaShanah and sealed on Yom Kippur. {27}
- There is a statement of R. Kruspedai which seems to contradict this notion. According to R. Kruspedia, there are three books that are opened on Rosh HaShanah, one is the book of "resha'im gemurim", the second is the book of "tzaddikim gemurim" and third is the book of beinonim. The tzaddikim gemurim are written and sealed immediately for life, the resha'im are written and sealed immediately for death and the beinonim are suspended until Yom Kippur. If they "merit" they are written for life and if they don't merit they are written for death. {28} This idea is developed further in the shiur outline on the Judgment of Rosh HaShanah.
- The Vilna Gaon (1720-1797) notes based on Tosafos that there are two judgments, one on Olam HaBah and one on Olam Hazeh. The Beraisa is dealing with Olam HaZeh and everyone is judged on Rosh HaShanah and sealed on Yom Kippur. R. Kruspedai is dealing with judgment of Olam HaBah. As such, it is not appropriate to mention anything about chasima until Yom Kippur (ostensibly the end of Yom Kippur). {29}
- R. Efraim Z. Margulies (1762-1828) notes that the reason why we should find strength to daven Neilah with fervor is that Yom Kippur is the close of the Aseres Yemei Teshuva and Neilah is the close of Yom Kippur and everything follows the closing. {30}
- When Mishna Berurah quotes this idea, he introduces it by stating that this is the moment that the chasimas hadin takes place.
- R. Shalom Schwadron (1815-1911) notes that if someone accidentally says כתבנו instead of חתמנו it is not problematic because חתימה includes כתיבה as well. {32}
- This highlights the fact that although we are praying to be sealed for good things, if we aren't currently slated for that, we also need to be first written for good things and then sealed. Thus חתמנו includes both writing and sealing.
- R. Meir Simcha of Dvinsk that the teshuva of Neilah is unique: {33}
- Whenever someone violates an aveirah, in addition to the actual aveirah, there is a chilul HaShem involved.
- Chilul HaShem is a form of rebellion against God, something that the Heavenly Court cannot condone and is only in the hands of God.
- During our judgment, the heavenly court is involved until the chasimah which is done be God himself.
- As such, Neilah, the time of chasimah presents a unique opportunity to atone for chilul HaShem and the chilul HaShem aspects of our aveiros. It is at this time when God sits in judgment alone and He can decide to condone our acts of chilul HaShem.