Skip to content
Parsha Pages

How Can I Believe That Yonah Was Swallowed By A Fish?

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The book of Yonah tells the famous story of a big fish (not whale) swallowing Yonah for three days until the prophet emerged unscathed. To someone like me with more of skeptical point-of-view, this episode is hard to swallow.

Yonah had fled from the land of Israel after G-d set for him an unpleasant task, encouraging the Jews' enemy to repent. But you can't hide from G-d. As Yonah's boat was sailing, a storm threatened to drown all the sailors who opted to save themselves by throwing Yonah overboard. Yonah was swallowed by a fish and remained alive inside it for three days. Yonah prayed to G-d, agreeing to fulfill his appointed task. The fish vomited Yonah onto dry land, enabling the prophet to continue on his path.

I've never been swallowed by an animal, but I'm pretty sure no human can survive the ordeal. Yonah should have been crushed, chewed, suffocated and starved, even if the fish somehow had food pipes large enough to allow an intact human body to flow through. This story seems quite unrealistic. The obvious response is that this is a miracle, but that seems a bit too easy.

Any implausible story, including magic tricks and mind reading cons, can be called a miracle. Does Judaism expect us to be gullible?

Rambam (Maimonides) reinterprets many miraculous stories of the Bible. For example, he believes that any time a person interacts with an angel, whether speaking, arguing or wrestling, the story represents a vision, not a physical interaction (Moreh Nevukhim 2:42). In a letter on the concept of a general resurrection, Rambam writes that he considers something a miracle only when it is explicitly identified as such and cannot be reinterpreted (Letters, ed. Kafach, p. 88). Rambam believes that we should not immediately take every miracle story at face value. Rather, we have to dig deeper and understand what really happened.

However, Rambam also believes that Judaism requires acceptance of the possibility of miracles. His primary objection to the idea of an eternal universe, which at the time was the scientific consensus, is that it precludes the possibility of miracles (Moreh Nevukhim 2:25). If G-d did not create the universe, if He did not author the laws of nature, then He cannot intervene in nature through miracles. A lack of belief in miracles constitutes a diminution of G-d's ability. His will is not absolute if He is handcuffed by the rules of nature. Belief in G-d's absolute ability includes the possibility of performing miracles. However, while miracles must be possible, they need not be frequent.

There are two types of belief in miracles — a Naturalist approach and an Interventionist view. Rambam seems to have moved from one to the other. In his earliest work, Rambam writes very clearly that all miracles were programmed into nature during Creation. The Sages of the Mishnah (Avos 5:6) list ten miraculous items that were created during the last moments of the six days of Creation. Rambam explains that this non-exhaustive list implies that, during the process of Creation, G-d built certain exceptions into the laws of nature. Any miracle that would ever occur was decided at that moment, by G-d, who is above time and history. In this way, miracles are a part of nature.

A midrash lists a few exceptions that were programmed into nature (Bereishis Rabbah 5:5). Among them are the sea splitting (Ex. 14), the sun stopping in its place (Josh. 6), ravens feeding Elijah (1 Kings 17), three Jewish leaders surviving being thrown into a furnace (Dan. 3), Daniel surviving the lion's den (Dan. 6) and Yonah surviving being swallowed by the fish (Yonah 2). This midrash accepts the Naturalist view. Any miracle that occurs in history must have been embedded along with the laws of nature during Creation.

Later in life, Rambam seems to have changed his mind. In some sense, this Naturalist view limits G-d's ability. An omnipotent G-d can intervene and change anything, even if not pre-programmed in Nature. Rambam writes that G-d actively changes nature by rewarding the fulfillment of commandments and punishing their violation (Moreh Nevukhim 3:32). This implies an Interventionist view, in which G-d temporarily modifies the laws of nature to allow for exceptions. Rambam even calls the idea that miracles are pre-programmed into Creation "very strange" (Moreh Nevukhim 2:29). Miracles are a temporary change of nature, a divine intervention.

I have not seen in traditional Bible commentaries, whether written by Naturalists or Interventionists, any attempt to reinterpret the story of Yonah and the fish. They seem to accept it as one of the few miracles in history. The book of Yonah (2:1) says, “And the L-rd prepared a great fish to swallow up Yonah." A midrash highlights the word "prepared,” suggesting that this miracle was already in existence since the time of Creation (Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, 10). While this midrash implies a Naturalist view of the miracle, an Interventionist would read this literally: G-d prepared the miraculous fish immediately through intervention in nature, and not centuries earlier.

Even someone who believes in miracles need not believe in frequent miracles. We can be suspicious of dubious claims without rejecting the concept of miracles. However, if we are skeptical of everything, we imply that G-d is incapable of intervening in the world He created. Effectively, we would be saying that G-d is bound by the rules of nature. However, G-d is bigger than any fish that swallowed Yonah and capable of anything.

More in this printout

View the whole printout