A summary chart of reasons why Yonah ran away
1. His mercy extends to all His creations – especially when they repent
- Pros: God's compassion on Nineveh is presented at the end of the book as a primary message to Yonah
- Cons: Difficult to understand Yonah's extreme opposition to the mission to Nineveh
2. Yonah objects to the repentance of the sinful Assyrian kingdom, since they are supposed to destroy Israel
- Pros: Historical and political context of Nineveh, capitol of Assyria, and the prophesy of Yonah ben Amitai, noted in the books of Kings and the Minor Prophets
- Cons: The main point is missing from the book (can one book be explained by another? The Book of Esther according to Ezra chapter 3)
3. Yonah is not prepared to be a false prophet, since he knew from the outset that his prophesy would not be fulfilled
- Pros: Yonah clearly explains that his running away is due to his fear that God will have mercy on Nineveh (4, 2)
- Cons: Difficult to understand Yonah's extreme opposition and why he is willing to die for it
4. The story of Yonah's running away teaches that God's word will come to pass and ‘no man can escape from God' (Abudarham)
- Pros: = the message of two chapters
- Cons: Why would Yona be so opposed to this extent? What is the importance of Nineveh and their repentance?