Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Why did he run away?

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

A summary chart of reasons why Yonah ran away

  • 1. His mercy extends to all His creations – especially when they repent

    • Pros: God's compassion on Nineveh is presented at the end of the book as a primary message to Yonah
    • Cons: Difficult to understand Yonah's extreme opposition to the mission to Nineveh
  • 2. Yonah objects to the repentance of the sinful Assyrian kingdom, since they are supposed to destroy Israel

    • Pros: Historical and political context of Nineveh, capitol of Assyria, and the prophesy of Yonah ben Amitai, noted in the books of Kings and the Minor Prophets
    • Cons: The main point is missing from the book (can one book be explained by another? The Book of Esther according to Ezra chapter 3)
  • 3. Yonah is not prepared to be a false prophet, since he knew from the outset that his prophesy would not be fulfilled

    • Pros: Yonah clearly explains that his running away is due to his fear that God will have mercy on Nineveh (4, 2)
    • Cons: Difficult to understand Yonah's extreme opposition and why he is willing to die for it
  • 4. The story of Yonah's running away teaches that God's word will come to pass and ‘no man can escape from God' (Abudarham)

    • Pros: = the message of two chapters
    • Cons: Why would Yona be so opposed to this extent? What is the importance of Nineveh and their repentance?

More in this printout

View the whole printout