Yonah's Obsession with the Beis HaMikdash
Based on an article from Rabbi Chaim Jachter and Binyamin Jachter
One of most striking features of Yonah's Tefillah recited while in the big fish, is the frequent mention of the Beis HaMikdash. Yonah refers to the Beis HaMikdash (or a Korban he will offer there) no less than three times (Pesukim 5, 8 and 10) in this brief Tefillah that occupies no more than eight Pesukim.
A focus on the Beis haMikdash seems quite incongruous considering that Yonah in trapped inside a fish. In such circumstances survival and rescue would appear to be the only thing that would occupy a reasonable person. For example, if someone were, heaven forfend, be trapped in a collapsed coal mine, one would focus on rescue and not envisioning a trip to one's favorite place of worship¹. Classic Mefarshim do not explicitly address this issue.
Da'as Mikra (to Yonah 2:2) writes that a similar Tefillah was commonly recited by sailors who were near death at sea and saved. These sailors would come to the Beis HaMikdash and offer Korbanos. According to this approach that Yonah tailored this commonly recited Tefillah to his situation, the focus on the Beis haMikdash is not specific to Yonah but rather to all who are rescued from deep peril and offer a Korban Todah.
Rav Dr. Meir Levin cites the Yerushalmi (Sukkah 5:1) to solve our problem. The Yerushalmi states “Rav Yonah said: Yonah son of Amitai was at pilgrimage to Jerusalem and he entered the rejoicing of water drawing (simchas Beis haShoeva) and the Holy Spirit rested upon him”. Rav Dr. Levin concludes “this explanation certainly throws light on Yonah's repeated reference to 'your holy temple' in his prayer from the belly of the fish²”.
Four additional approaches to this unusual phenomenon.
Explanation Number One - The Goal of Yonah's Resistance
Torah Academy of Bergen County student Eli Englard suggested that Yonah is focused on the Beis HaMikdash since this is the goal of his resisting HaShem's command to address Nineveh. Recall Abarbanel's approach that Yonah desired Nineveh's demise since Nineveh the capital of Assyria has designs on conquering Eretz Yisrael. As such, Yonah's ultimate goal is to protect the Beis HaMikdash from the threat posed to it by the Assyrians³.
According to this approach, while still in the fish Yonah is resisting HaShem's anticipated forgiving of Nineveh. This approach is in harmony with Abarbanel and Malbim's approach to another portion of Yonah's Tefillah (2:9) which they interpret as a complaint Yonah lodges that Nineveh's Teshuvah will not be long lasting.
Yonah might be trying to push his agenda a bit further in the Tefillah. His goal is to convince HaShem to not forgive Nineveh. Yonah is showing how he isn't thinking short term but rather much longer and broader term with all of Bnei Yisrael and its Dveikus (deep commitment) to HaShem in the balance.
Explanation Number Two - The Beis HaMikdash as the Ideal of Truth
Rav Raphi Mandelstam, my respected colleague at Torah Academy of Bergen County, offers an intriguing approach. He argues that the essence of Yonah is his devotion to truth, as indicated by his name Yonah ben Amitai (the root of Amitai is Emet, the truth). Accordingly, although the Beis HaMikdash is extremely meaningful to every Jew, it is even more meaningful to Yonah since it represents the pinnacle of truth.
The high standards of Taharah, such as observing Taharah to the fourth degree (Revee’ee L’Tumah) instead of the usual second degree of Tumah (Sheini L'Tumah) is an example of the lofty ideals attained in the Beis HaMikdash and nowhere else. The perfection of Taharah achieved in the preparation of the Parah Adumah described in the opening Perakim of Masechet Parah are another example. In the Beis haMikdash even an errant thought such as Pigul (thinking about eating or offering a Korban outside the precincts of the Beis haMikdash or proper time parameters) disqualifies the offering. Kohanim or animals with blemishes may not be involved in the service/Avodah in the Beis HaMikdash.
All this represents a high achievement of Torah ideals and is the type of uncompromised and unvarnished truth to which Yonah ben Amitai aspires. Thus, we are hardly surprised that of all people Yonah ben Amitai is obsessed with the Beis HaMikdash. In the words of Torah Academy of Bergen County student Max Krantz, the Beis HaMikdash serves as Yonah's "happy place" to which he retreats in his imagination to mentally escape the severe stress of being trapped inside a fish.
Explanation Number Three - Yonah as a Representative of Am Yisrael
Torah Academy of Bergen County Talmid Gilad Ginsberg offers a suggestion based on Rashi's assertion (Bereshis 15:10 s.v. Et HaTzipor) that the dove (Yonah) symbolizes Am Yisrael. This is a most compelling comparison considering that the dove constitutes the paradigmatic kosher bird.
Gilad further suggest that Yonah trapped in the fish yet at the same time saved by the fish from drowning in the great sea, represents the Jewish people saved by the Galus (exile) yet at the same time trapped in the Galus. Thus, just as Yonah is obsessed with the Beis haMikdash while trapped in the great fish, so too the Jewish People remain obsessed with the Beis HaMikdash even at the darkest moments of the Exile. Indeed, the Beis HaMikdash is a ubiquitous feature of our Tefilllos and Zemiros. At a typical Orthodox Jewish wedding, at least half of the songs sung mention the Beis HaMikdash.
The Talmud Bavli does not encompass most of Seder Zera’im since most of the Halachos that appear in this Seder do not apply in the Exile. Nonetheless, the Bavli devotes much attention to Seder Kodashim which focus on Korbanos, despite their not applying in the Exile. In fact, two very large Masechetos, Zevachim and Menachos reflect the great attention the Babylonian sages devoted to Korbanos despite the fact that they are not offered in the Exile. Another expression set by Yonah of continued preoccupation with the Beis HaMikdash even in exile.
In essence the Beis HaMikdash expresses the presence of HaShem among Am Yisrael. Indeed, the paradigm for the Beis HaMikdash is the Pasuk, “V'Asu Li Mikdash V’Shachanti B'Tocham”, make for me a Mikdash and I will reside in them (Shemos 25:8)4. The words "in them" refer to the Jewish People. By focusing on the Beis HaMikdash even at are lowest ebb, we articulate are firm belief that HaShem will never abandon His people and his presence remains even in the midst of the Galus (Megillah 29a).
Explanation Number Four - Think Big Even at Lowest Point
Perhaps Yonah focusing on the Beis HaMikdash from the darkness of the fish sets the Jewish paradigm of thinking "big" even at the most desperate of times. This is most appropriate for a special people whose destiny is to bring Bracha to the entire world (Bereishis 12:3).
Examples of such behavior include (as recounted by Rav Avraham Pam) Jews going to the Nazi gas chambers chanting "Mir Zennen Zei Ibberleben” (we will outlive them). This most certainly has happened as the Jewish people today greatly surpass the achievements of the German people in a virtually every area of human endeavors. A more mundane example Jews harboring bold ambitions in difficult times is the bold launching of the extraordinarily successful Israel Aircraft Industry in the early 1950's at a time when the newly born State of Israel was struggling to find food and housing for many its citizens.
Yonah sets the model for Jews' high ambitions despite seemingly impossible obstacles that stand in the way of achieving the dreams. Perhaps this phenomenon explains Yaakov Avinu's highly improbable successful bovine venture despite the fact that Lavan had provided him with the lowest quality livestock as his venture capital (Bereishis 30:36 with Rashi). Yaakov's strategy of peeled streaks placed before the sheep when they drank seems to have no scientific basis. Despite it the severe handicaps, Yaakov Avinu still emerged as an enormous financial success. Perhaps the reason for Yaakov Avinu's success is that when a Jew has faith in the most dire of circumstances HaShem often manipulates the situation for us to attain great achievements. It seems that HaShem rewards Jews for harboring high ambitions. After all, the destiny of our people is to achieve high levels of success.
Conclusion
Great and profound ideas lie dormant embedded in Sefer Yonah. We need only to think deeply and HaShem will help us uncover these great lessons taught by Sefer Yonah. HaShem apparently rewards those who harbor high ambitions in their learning of this great Sefer.
1 (Torah.org class number eight on Sefer Yonah) The analogy might not be the most apt one, however, since Yonah knew that HaShem wasn't going to kill him, because He would have sent the large fish to save Yonah from drowning. Yonah realizes he's in a state of limbo, not living but not dead yet. He had to think beyond of the scope of his situation.
2 We must also consider that Yonah resided in the Northern Kingdom at a time when its less than excellent kings maintained a barrier to prevent Aliyah L'Regel. Yonah must have had to make an extraordinary effort to defy the government edict. Interestingly, Chazal (Eruvin 96a) depict Yonah's wife as sharing her husband's love for the Beis HaMikdash. Chazal record that Yonah's wife also made Aliyah L'Regel and the Chachamim did not object. It is interesting that of all the wives of Tzadikim, only the wife of Yonah is mentioned as having made Aliyah L'Regel. This certainly fits with our understanding that Yonah harbored a special affinity and love for the Beis HaMikdash.
3 See Melachim II 16:12-18 for a description of the damage indirectly caused by the Assyrians to the Beis HaMikdash. The Assyrians also likely influenced the evil king Menashe in his defiling of the Temple.
4 It is clear from the Rambam (Hilchos Beis HaBechirah 1:1) that this Pasuk refers not only to the Mishkan but also to the Beis HaMikdash.