Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Sefer Yonah

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Based on Rabbi Joshua Flug

  1. Introduction

    This shiur outline will cover some of the themes of Sefer Yonah, particularly as they relate to Yom Kippur. [The source sheet does not contain the pesukim from Yonah. It would helpful if the one has the complete text, which is available here.] The following resources are very helpful:

    1. Michlelet Herzog has a collection of articles on Sefer Yonah. The articles by R. Avraham Rivlin and R. Netiv were used to help prepare this shiur outline.

    2. Article by R. Yehuda Shaviv

    3. Article by R. Yosef Rivlin on the Vilna Gaon's commentary to Yonah.

  2. Why Do We Read Yonah On Yom Kippur?

    1. The Gemara (Megilah 31a) states that we read Yonah for the haftarah of Mincha on Yom Kippur.

    2. Rashi (1040-1105) writes that we read it because of the teshuva of the people of Nineveh.

    3. R. David Avudraham (14th century) writes that we read it because we learn from Yonah that you cannot run away from your aveiros. (Sder Tefilas Yom haKippur)

    4. R. Shaviv notes two more connections to Yom Kippur.

      1. There is an element of goral in both. The se'ir l'azazel (the goat sent away) was chosen through goral. Similarly, the sailors used a goral to determine who was at fault for the sinking ship.

      2. The Torah reading of Yom Kippur has the concept of וחי בהם, that the preservation of life takes precedence over observance of mitzvos. By contrast, Yonah took the opposite approach and preferred death over fulfillment of the 'רצון ה.

    5. From the fact that we read all four chapters of Yonah, the implication is that there are multiple ideas that we can learn relevant to Yom Kippur. We will highlight some of them.

  3. Running Away from One's Life Mission

    1. The Rishonim ask: How could a navi think that it is possible to run away from G-d? Radak (1160-1235) suggests that he wasn't hiding, but rather leaving Eretz Yisrael and since nevuah is only given in Eretz Yisrael, Yonah would no longer be eligible for nevuah. (Yonah 1,3)

    2. Accordingly, the message that Yonah was given was that he can't exempt himself from his mission. He was sent numerous signs to illustrate this point:

      1. The captain tells Yonah קום קרא (1:6) the very same words that G-d used to instruct Yonah to speak to Nineveh (1:2).

      2. The goral falls on Yonah (1:7).

      3. After Yonah is thrown overboard, a miracle occurs that he survives by being swallowed by a fish and another miracle occurs that he is able to live inside (2:1).

    3. Pirkei D' Rabbi Eliezer (Chapter 10) states that Yonah didn't want to go to Nineveh because a similar thing happened with him and the Jewish people. He gave a prophecy that they would be destroyed, and they did teshuva and were spared but Yonah was accused of being a navi sheker.

    4. The Yalkut Shimoni states that Yonah tried to kill himself to avoid carrying out his mission.

      1. R. Shaviv notes that one indication to this is that he specifically went to Tarshish. The verse in Tehillim (48:8) states ברוח קדים תשבר אניות תרשיש implying that boats going between Eretz Yisrael and Tarshish were prone to accidents.

      2. Another indication is the fact that Yonah goes to sleep when everyone else is trying to figure out how to save the ship.

      3. When the goral falls on Yonah, he asks them to throw him overboard despite their attempts to continue to save the ship.

    5. Putting these ideas together, Yonah's reputation was more important to him than his own life. He would have preferred to die (and make it look like an accident) rather than walk around with the reputation of a navi sheker (false prophet). This is an important message about how we have to strengthen ourselves so that worrying about our reputation doesn't prevent us from carrying out our mission in life. On Yom Kippur, we commit to make certain changes to our lives, some of which may not be popular or that may lead to others mocking us, and we need to look at what is important.

  4. Teshuva of Chesed and Teshuva of Din

    1. The Mishna (Taanis 15a) derives aspects of teshuva from the teshuva of Nineveh.

    2. Yet, Yonah didn't see their teshuva as sincere. In fact, even after Nineveh is spared, Yonah waits outside the city anticipating that they will falter (עד אשר יראה מה יהיה בעיר 4:5). We see Yonah's approach to life and then G-d's response to him through the kikayon (shade-providing tree):

      1. Aside from the obvious message of compassion, there is a deeper understanding. When G-d says אתה חסת על הקיקיון He wasn't highlighting Yonah's compassion for the kikayon, but rather Yonah's regret over the loss of the kikayon. חס can mean being compassionate, but it can also mean protecting an inanimate object from damage (see for example Bereishis 45:20- ועיניכם אל תחס על כליכם). Yonah didn't care about the life of the kikayon, but rather about the fact that it was there to protect him from the sun. His “compassion” for the kikayon was motivated by self-interest. As such, perhaps G-d was telling Yonah that if G-d's only role was to judge people, then Yonah would be correct. However, G-d is also the Creator, and in that capacity, G-d “invests” in His creations. If Yonah can show unusual concern and care for a kikayon that he didn't invest in, how much more so, should G-d show great care for His creations?

    3. The Yerushalmi (Makkos 2,6) states the chochma and nevuah were asked what the consequences are for someone who sins, and they responded that he must be punished. G-d was then asked the same question and He responded that they should do teshuva. Yonah's approach seems to follow what the Yerushalmi describes as the approach of nevuah. The dialogue between G-d and Yonah matches the dialogue found in the Yerushalmi.

      1. Yonah has a focus on "emes”. When Yonah states G-d's attributes, he leaves out emes (כי אתה א-ל חנון ורחום ארך אפים ורב חסד ונחם על הרעה 4:2). Furthermore, this could be why he is called ben Amitai. This seems to be what the Yerushalmi refers to as the claim of chochma. Intellectually, it doesn't make sense to forgive people. There is a lack of emes when one does so. Yet, G-d considers this to be emes as well. There is an ultimate truth that takes chesed into consideration.

    4. R. Yosef D. Soloveitchik (1903-1993) in Al HaTeshuva (page 25) discusses whether is teshuva is a chesed or whether we are entitled to it. He suggests that if one performs teshuva where one returns to G-d and restores the relationship with Him, then it works even within middas hadin. However, if the teshuva is more superficial, the teshuva is a chesed from HaShem. Perhaps this was Yonah's error:

      1. R. Yitzchak Abarbanel (1437-1508) notes that Nineveh didn't give up avodah zarah. They were being punished for not treating one another properly and that is all they did teshuva for.

      2. Yonah was focused on teshuva as a transformative act of repairing the relationship with G-d and didn't accept the concept of teshuva of chesed. The people of Nineveh didn't do that and therefore, according to Yonah, deserved punishment.

  5. Yonah's Transformation

    Building on the ideas in the previous sections, we can see Yonah's transformation taking place in a few stages:

    1. Yonah's initial reluctance to go to Nineveh was based on a concern for his reputation. That seems to change when he is in the belly of the fish.

      1. Yonah refers to his experience as comparable to Gehinnom (מבטן שאול שועתי 2:3)

      2. He no longer wants to die, but he still expresses reluctance to carry out the mission, this time, not because of his reputation, but because of his skepticism of teshuva. He notes that he has personally changed and contrasts himself to those whose teshuva is superficial (משמרים הבלי שוא חסדם יעזבו ואני אשר נדרתי אשלמה 2:9-10).

        1. Rambam (1138-1204) writes that teshuva gemurah (complete teshuvah) requires a complete abandoning of the sin such that G-d himself can testify to the person's sincerity and that the person does not plan on returning to sin. (Hilchos Teshuvah 2,1-2)

        2. While this is true of teshuva gemurah, Yonah failed to recognize a lower level of teshuva and just as he knew that the sailors would return to their old ways, he knew that even if Nineveh listened to him, they would soon return to their old ways.

    2. When Yonah goes to Nineveh to deliver the message, it is very terse, almost as if he is doing it just to be yotzei (fulfill the bare minimum)

    3. The teshuva of Nineveh is accepted, and this causes Yonah a lot of anguish.

      1. It is interesting that the word רע appears throughout the fourth perek with two connotations: evil and suffering. Yonah seems to equate the suffering that he is experiencing with the evil that was carried out by Nineveh before they did teshuva and with the punishment that was intended for them.

      2. Why is Yonah so depressed? Is it because he is going to be known as a navi sheker? Is it because he became so transfixed with the idea that G-d must judge with middas hadin that he can't live any longer?

    4. The kikayon was meant to be a response to Yonah:

      1. You care more about yourself than others. The loss of the kikayon causes you severe anguish, but you can't have any compassion for the people of Nineveh?

      2. You fail to see the big picture when it comes to the way G-d Judges people. It is not simply about retribution, but there is compassion involved as well.

    5. The Navi doesn't tell us how Yonah reacted, but assuming he accepted the tochachah (reproach), this was Yonah's wake up call to form a new perspective on life.

More in this printout

View the whole printout