Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Why was Sefer Yonah Included in Tanach?

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

אמתי לאמר גדולה וקרא ניוויקם יונה הוה וירד יפו שויתן שכרה ישישה מלפני ולהאלהים החשבהלהשבר

The Question

Why was Sefer Yonah Included in Tanach?

The Radak begins his commentary on Sefer Yonah with a basic question:

One might ask: Why was this prophecy [of Yonah] written in the Kisvei ha'Kodesh, seeing as how (a) it is entirely about Ninveh, which belonged to the gentile nations, and (b) it contains no mention whatsoever of Israel? There is nothing like this in all of the Books of the Neviim.

Before we tackle this question, it would be prudent to review Chazal's general criterion for which prophecies were included in Kisvei ha'Kodesh and which were not:

Many prophets arose for Yisrael - twice as many as the [number of Jews who] left Egypt - but only those prophecies which were necessary for [future] generations were written down, while those which were not needed for future generations were not written (Megilah 14a).

Rashi (ad loc.) explains the phrase "a prophecy which was necessary for [future] generations" to mean "[a prophecy which was necessary in order] to teach teshuvah or horaah (instruction)."

One might think that this statement of Chazal paves the way for an answer to the Radak's question, namely, by allowing us to infer that Sefer Yonah was written and included in Kisvei haKodesh in order to teach some lesson in teshuvah or horaah to future generations. Upon further scrutiny, however, we see that this statement of Chazal is the basis of the Radak's question. Chazal introduced their principle with the words: "Many prophets arose for Yisrael." The Radak is bothered by the fact that Yonah didn't "arise for Yisrael" at all! He prophesied to Ninveh and didn't even mention Yisrael!

Radak offers three answers to his own question. The Abravanel objects to the Radak's first answer and provides an answer of his own.

Answer #1: Catalyst for Teshuvah

Radak's first answer is probably the most well-known:

It is possible to explain that [Sefer Yonah] was written in order to serve as a mussar (disciplinary teaching) to Yisrael, for behold a foreign nation which has no relation to Yisrael was close to doing teshuvah, and they actually did teshuvah shleimah from their evil the first time they were rebuked by a navi. [On the other hand,] Yisrael was rebuked day and night by neviim, and didn't do teshuvah from their wickedness.

In other words, Sefer Yonah is meant to serve as a standing rebuke to Bnei Yisrael by drawing our attention to Ninveh as a paradigmatic response to a navi's call to teshuvah and inspiring us to follow in Ninveh's footsteps.

This explanation is reflected in the selection of Sefer Yonah as the haftorah for minchah of Yom ha'Kippurim. Why else would we read this sefer on the final day of teshuvah, if not to inspire us to do teshuvah like the people in the story? Similarly, back when public fasts were decreed on account of catastrophes (e.g. droughts, plagues, wars), Sefer Yonah played an integral part of the halachically mandated communal teshuvah procedure, as outlined by the Rambam in Hilchos Taaniyos 4:2:

Afterwards, one of the wise elders [of the community] stands before them while they are sitting. If there is no wise elder, a man of wisdom should be chosen. If there is no man of wisdom, a man of stature should be chosen. He should speak words of rebuke to them, telling them: "Brethren, it is not sackcloth and fasting that will have an effect, but rather teshuvah and good deeds. This is evident from [the story of] Ninveh. It is not stated with regard to the people of Nineveh, 'And G-d saw their sackcloth and their fasting,' but rather, 'And G-d saw their deeds' (Yonah 3:10). Similarly, in the words of the prophetic tradition, it is written, 'Rend your hearts and not your garments' (Yoel 2:13)" He should continue in this vein according to his ability until they are humbled and turn [to G-d] in complete repentance.

Abravanel doesn't buy the Radak's explanation:

If we were to explain that [Sefer Yonah] was written as a mussar to Yisrael, to motivate them to do teshuvah like the citizens of Ninveh, this would be an extremely weak explanation. If Bnei Yisrael won't take mussar from the mitzvos of the Torah and the words of the Neviim, how will they take mussar from the actions of the citizens of Ninveh?

Furthermore, nowhere is it mentioned that the bamos (altars), pesilim (graven images), and false G-ds were removed from Ninveh, because they still held fast to all of these things, in spite of their teshuvah. What, exactly, is the mussar that Bnei Yisrael are supposed to take from that [partial kind of teshuvah]?

The Abravanel is bothered by two points: (1) if the neviim sent to our own nation failed to motivate us to do teshuvah, then the neviim sent to another nation will certainly won't motivate us; (2) how can we look to Ninveh as our role model for teshuvah if their teshuvah wasn't complete? They neglected to do teshuvah for the most severe sin of avodah zarah! What kind of message does that send to Bnei Yisrael? That's like trying to inspire a teenager to become a straight-A student by pointing to another student who raised her grade in Art Class from a D to an A, but who flunked out of Math, History, and English! (Reminder: I'm preparing to teach Yonah to high school students; please excuse any mashalim which you find to be unrelatable.)

Answer #1A: Yonah's Piety (etc.)

In the meantime, the Abravanel offers his own explanation for why Sefer Yonah was included in Kisvei ha'Kodesh: Rather, Sefer Yonah was written [and included] among the Kisvei ha'Kodesh not on account of Ninveh, but on account of Yonah, and the strength of his piety, and the miracle that was done on his behalf, and in order that we should know that the word of G-d will forever be established. Whereas the Radak's answer places Ninveh in the spotlight, the Abravanel maintains that Ninveh is merely the backdrop for the lessons to be learned from the prophet Yonah and his odyssey, with all of its ups and downs.

these two views of Sefer Yonah lead to two different experiences when learning the sefer. Based on the Radak's answer, our focus in learning Sefer Yonah should be the lessons about teshuvah that we learn from Ninveh. According to the Abravanel, our main focus should be on Yonah's struggle and HaShem's dialogue with him.

Answer #2: The Miracle of the Fish

The Radak offers a second explanation for why Sefer Yonah was included in Kisvei ha'Kodesh:

Furthermore, [Sefer Yonah was written] in order to make known the great miracle that G-d (blessed is He) did with the navi, namely, [that He enabled] him to be in the bowels of the fish for three days and three nights and live; furthermore, that He caused the fish to vomit him up.

The miracle of the fish is certainly the most well-known feature of the story. Say the name "Jonah" and most people will automatically associate to the phrase "and the whale." As far as miracles go, this was certainly an impressive one. A human being was sustained for three days and three nights in the belly of a fish and survived even after being vomited out.

Still, some might find this answer to be difficult to swallow. Although the Ralbag (Shemos 1:7) maintains that the derech ha'Torah is to publicize all miracles, since miracles serve as a proof of G-d's Existence and His role in guiding mankind, is this really enough to warrant including the entirety of Sefer Yonah in Kisvei ha'Kodesh? After all, the miracle of the fish only takes up one out of the four chapters in the sefer.

Perhaps, the Radak introduced this answer with the word, "Furthermore ..." he did not mean to imply that the miracle of the fish would, in and of itself, be sufficient to include Sefer Yonah in Kisvei ha'Kodesh; rather, the miracle of the fish is another reason why Yonah's prophecy rises to the level of being a "Scripture-worthy" prophecy. In other words, the miracle that happened to Yonah might have been an important factor in the Anshei Kneset ha'Gedolah's decision to include Sefer Yonah.

Answer #3: G-d Accepts Baalei Teshuvah

The third and final explanation offered by the Radak:

Furthermore, [Sefer Yonah was written] to teach that G-d (blessed is He) is compassionate to those who do teshuvah, no matter what nation they are from, and that He forgives them - especially if they are many.

There are several lessons to be gained from this explanation. First is the point which is explicitly highlighted by the Radak, namely, that G-d accepts all baalei teshuvah - no matter who they are, and no matter where they are from - and that He is abundant in mercy, compassion, and forgiveness. This theme is treated at length by the Rambam in Hilchos Teshuvah 7:6-7:

Teshuvah is great for it draws a man close to the shechinah, as it is stated: "Return, O Yisrael, to HaShem, your G-d" (Hoshea 14:2), and it is stated: ""Return to Me,' says HaShem" (Amos 4:6), and it is stated: "'If, you will return, O Yisrael,' says HaShem, 'You will return to Me'" (Yirmiyahu 4:1). In other words, if you will return in teshuvah, you will cling to Me.

Teshuvah brings near those who were far removed [from HaShem]. Previously, this person was hated by G-d, disgusting, far removed, and abominable. Now, he is beloved and desirable, close, and dear ...

How exalted is the level of teshuvah! Previously, the [transgressor] was separate from G-d, the Lord of Israel, as it is stated: "Your sins separate between you and your G-d" (Yeshayahu 59:2). He would call out [to G-d] without being answered as it is stated: "Even if you pray many times, I will not hear" (Yeshayahu 1:15). He would fulfill mitzvot, only to have them crushed before him as states: "Who asked this from you, to trample in My courts?" (ibid. 1:12), and it is stated: "If only there were someone among you who would shut the [Temple] doors, so that you could not kindle upon My altar in vain!” (Malachi 1:10), and it is stated: "Add your burnt-offerings to your peace-offerings and eat [their] meat!" (Yirmiyahu 7:21).

But now he is clinging to the shechinah, as it is stated: "And you who cling to HaShem, your G-d" (Devarim 4:4). He calls out [to G-d] and is answered immediately as states: "Before you will call out, I will answer" (Yeshayahu 65:24). He fulfills mitzvot and they are accepted with pleasure and joy as it is stated, "G-d has already accepted your deeds" (Koheles 9:7), and it is stated: "Then, shall the offering of Yehudah and Yerushalayim be pleasing to G-d as in days of old and as in the former years" (Malachi 3:4).

This is a significant point on multiple levels. Philosophically, it is important to know that a person can completely and instantaneously change his metaphysical standing before G-d (whatever that means) from one extreme to the other. Psychologically, it is important for the transgressor to know that complete redemption is possible - otherwise, he might give up hope and feel "doomed" by his sins. It is also important to know how the status of a baal teshuvah is regarded from the vantage-point of Torah and mitzvos (e.g. a baal teshuvah's tefilos are answered, his mitzvos are accepted, etc.). From Ninveh in particular we see that teshuvah is so powerful that it can overturn a decree of destruction, even though the nation had descended to the utmost levels of depravity.

Radak's third explanation may be summarized as follows: Sefer Yonah illustrates that teshuvah is not essentially a religious phenomenon, but a human phenomenon.

One of the biggest obstacles when teaching high school students about teshuvah is that they are still locked into an extremely narrow view of what teshuvah is. To many religious teenagers, "teshuvah" entails feeling guilty for speaking lashon ha'ra, klopping an al cheit for that time they ate a candy bar without a hechsher, and texting all of their friends a frantic, "Are you mochel me?" before the Aseres Ymei Teshuvah deadline is up. I have even encountered a number of freshmen who seem to think that teshuvah involves little more than regretting what you did and saying that you're sorry, whether to G-d or to another person.

Teshuvah is far broader than that. Real teshuvah is a process which involves every single aspect of human development. The Rambam introduces Hilchos Teshuvah by saying "the explanation of this mitzvah, and the fundamental principles which are dragged along with it, because of it, will be explained in the following chapters" - and he is quite serious. His Hilchos Teshuvah begins with "halachic teshuvah," but goes on to describe the darchei teshuvah, how G-d judges the world, the criteria for entry into olam ha'ba, free will, reward and punishment, berachos and klalos, lishmah and she'lo lishmah, and many more topics. The majority of these topics are pertinent not only to Jews who observe the system of 613 commandments, but to non-Jews as well.

What better way to illustrate this point than by focusing on a real-world instance of teshuvah which was completely "non-religious" in character, and which didn't involve any Jews? The teshuvah of Ninveh was from the transgressions of chamas (i.e. violence, theft, robbery, battery, etc.), which is bein adam l'chaveiro on the most basic societal level. By pondering their teshuvah from this sin, we will come to recognize that our teshuvah has the same fundamental objective, namely, to help us to live as human beings, which is the purpose of the entire Torah.

More in this printout

View the whole printout